David Olson wrote:
{Quote hidden}>
> This is a philosophical post...
>
> As I pass through the many phases of emotions while PICing (mostly elation
> and depression), I tend to look at alternatives when depressed.
>
> Like:
>
> Other microcontroller companies - do they have better tools, third-party
> support, etc.
> PIC derivatives - BasicStamp, etc.
> Other languages - C, Basic, etc.
>
> So, questions begin:
>
> Why wouldn't I go with, let's say, Motorola?
> Does anybody use BasicStamps (or other high-level interpreted chips) in
> commercial products?
>
> One of the biggest reasons I went the PIC route is the massive external
> support. Motorola, Intel, TI, etc. seem to have more of a "corporate"
> catering. In other words, I didn't get the sense as an individual with a
> dream, I would get some help from the Motorola community (could be wrong
> though...). It also helped that my local Microchip rep was much more
> friendly than the Motorola one.
>
> We'll keep the language question out of this since there are volumes of
> PICMail on the subject already.
You are very lucky in the sense that you can compare
apples with apples before committing to any vendor.
Mchip has a very active hobbyist/student following
that they are looking after well. The reason is simple -
once you've got yourself going on a micro, it is a lot
of trouble to switch to another.
ATMEL is selling at half the price of Mchip, and are
*very* aggressively stealing the loyalty away from
Mchip. They have also seen how strong the loyalty of
us suckers can be.
Scenix, being the more flexible company, also realised
that starting with a micro is expensive, so they are
selling a programmer *and* emulator at around $200-$250
depending on where you are. The parts are flash, and
they are working on a whole range of plug-in software
modules that you can use (RS232, I2C, LCD, SPI etc).
Damn nice micro.
Motorola is quite cheap, but the support and lead
times stink. If you are not going to sell more than
10 trillion / year, you don't have an ear.
--
Friendly Regards /"\
\ /
Tjaart van der Walt X ASCII RIBBON CAMPAIGN
spam_OUTtjaartTakeThisOuT
wasp.co.za / \ AGAINST HTML MAIL
|--------------------------------------------------|
| WASP International |
|R&D Engineer : GSM peripheral services development|
|--------------------------------------------------|
| Mobile : .....tjaartKILLspam
@spam@sms.wasp.co.za (160 text chars) |
| http://www.wasp.co.za/~tjaart/index.html |
|Voice: +27-(0)11-622-8686 Fax: +27-(0)11-622-8973|
| WGS-84 : 26¡10.52'S 28¡06.19'E |
|--------------------------------------------------|